Parish Lenten Mission, 2023: Frere Andre, The "Miracle-Man" of Montreal Conference V: "He Hath Done All Things Well"
“And they bring to Jesus one deaf and mute: and they besought Him that He would lay His hand upon him. And taking him from the multitude apart, He put His fingers into his ears: and spitting He touched his tongue. And looking up to Heaven, He groaned and said to him: Ephpheta, which is, Be thou opened. And immediately his ears were opened and the string of his tongue was loosed and he spoke right. And He charged them that they should tell no man. But the more He charged them, so much the more a great deal did they publish it. And so much the more did they wonder, saying: He hath done all things well. He hath made both the deaf to hear and the mute to speak.”
—St. Mark 7:32-37
By 1890, 20 years after Alfred Bessette had taken the name-in-religion “André”, his reputation had spread far and wide that he was a miracle-man, un faiseur des miracles! In spite of the derision from within his own Community, the visitors seeking Frere André kept coming in ever greater numbers. Some parents of the school-boys lodged a protest with the College authorities: all of these sick people coming to see Frere André were likely vectors of infection for their children, they claimed with indignation. They demanded it be stopped!
An ingenious solution was found. In 1893, when a new tram-way line was built, linking downtown Montreal to the small neighborhood of Cote-des-Neiges, the Superior of the College negotiated with the authorities to have a stop near the school. When this happened, they sent Frere André down to the tramway stop to receive his visitors apart from the College. This was his reception room for a dozen years until he had a new one built by the first small chapel of the Oratoire Saint Joseph.
At this point in our story we do well to consider the place of miracles in God’s Divine Providence. I draw here from the book Brother André by the Montreal priest Jean-Guy Dubuc, published in English translation in 1999. We read in the Gospel Books how Jesus was a great worker of miracles. Even His enemies had to concede that He performed some extraordinary things which could not be explained.
Why did He do them? He did them at once to reward the faith which had already been shown and to express the charity of God. Fr. Dubuc explains:
Miracles can be fully understood—that is, perceived as acts of God’s love—only by those who believe in Him. Unbelievers can see only conjuring tricks or sorry acts of magic, all more or less spectacular or comprehensible. For one has to be prepared, to be readied for the sign, in order to recognize it when it appears and to understand its meaning...
...As related in the Gospels, Jesus’ miracles always linked the human, indeed the humane, to the Divine. They were invoked by a cry for help, expressed directly by persons in need or by others on their behalf. Thus initially, it is love for a person that triggers divine intervention. But also, Jesus’ actions are either preceded or followed by an act of faith. Miracles, being visible signs of a supernatural presence, can be accepted fully for what they are only in a context of faith. Without faith, they cannot be recognized, much less understood.
A miracle is a sign directed exclusively to the faithful.
A miracle is not a right that can be claimed. It is always an exceptional and gratuitous favor.
It is with this understanding that we should approach the miraculous in Frere André’s life. And then we can see just how abundantly the Divine Pity was poured out in answer to the Brother’s compassionate prayer for others.