Cardinal Sean:
“The leak of Justice Alito’s draft opinion on abortion has brought many voices into a conflicted question now almost fifty years old. Throughout those years, from the Roe v. Wade decision until today, the Catholic Church has been part of the abortion debate in this country. Two characteristics have marked our position. First, while Catholic moral teaching has opposed abortion since the apostolic era, the case we have made to our religiously pluralistic nation is that abortion is fundamentally a human rights question. Such questions are argued in rational terms: the right in danger is the right to life. Its defense in the public arena can and should be articulated in ways which those of any faith or no faith can analyze and understand. We have tried to make that case and will continue to do so whatever the final decision of the Court will be. Second, the human rights argument means that human life must be protected before birth and after birth. A pro-life position does not end at birth; it must extend to a public vision which encompasses the common good of our society. The child whose life is protected by the moral and civil law deserves the support of a society which will provide the socio-economic conditions in which life can flourish.”
“A draft opinion will not settle our long national debate. As it goes forward, before and after the final decision is made, my hope is that all participants will respect the dignity of others; on a question as deep as the one we seek to decide this attitude is essential.”
(Our Archbishop Seàn Cardinal O’Malley released this statement at the end of last week, May 13th.)
- - -
Fr. Higgins:
I think it is important for us to be aware of this public statement of Cardinal Seàn, and to note its measured and restrained tone. Since the leaked draft hit the news there has been a hurricane of public hatred directed at the pro-life position and at the Catholic Church in particular. This public hatred has been amplified by the media outrage culture. Last week’s Boston Pilot
gave news coverage to the calls for disruption of Catholic Masses around the U.S. between May 8th-14th, and of actual incidents of disruption or vandalism of churches.
It shouldn’t be necessary to say, but it has to be said and Cardinal Seàn has said it in his Statement—the Catholic Church’s witness against the wrongness of legalized abortion in this country is not an attempt to impose a “theocracy” or a peculiar religious dogma on a religiously pluralistic and secular society. It has been framed, and will continue to be framed, as a human rights issue which is accessible to reason and can be argued in rational terms. Moreover, as the Cardinal says, “A pro-life position does not end at birth; it must extend to a public vision which encompasses the common good of our society.”
It is a libelous falsehood to say that the Catholic Church cares only about stopping abortions to the detriment of a larger social vision for the children actually born. If the U.S. Supreme Court actually does overturn Roe v. Wade it would remove only what has been the chief legal obstacle to protecting unborn life in this country for the last half-century. In so many important ways, however, the Pro-life work will have just begun.
Mary Immaculate of Lourdes is Newton and Needham Massachusetts' oldest Roman Catholic Parish. Founded as Saint Mary Parish in 1870, it was renamed "Mary Immaculate of Lourdes" when the new Church was dedicated on Thanksgiving Day, 1910. In addition to being a regular territorial parish of the Archdiocese of Boston it is also a "Mission Parish" since 2007 with a special apostolate for the Traditional Latin Mass (1962 Missal).
Mary Immaculate of Lourdes Church
270 Elliot Street
Newton, MA 02464
USA
Copyright © 2025 Mary Immaculate of Lourdes Parish. All Rights Reserved.